It cannot be satisfied from within its own terms, and it cannot be confronted from within them either, because the confrontation enters the terms. This is the precision Girard approached and Böhme completes.
🜃
INTENTION IS DOWNSTREAM OF IT
The one who recognizes the mimetic mechanism, who sees the triangle and names the rivalry and understands the scapegoat, does not thereby exit. Recognition is a move made inside, and a recognized desire is still desire.
It operates below intention's floor. What the appetite leans towards before any deliberate selecting begins is not available to intention. Intention can redirect the surface; the current underneath runs where it runs. The soul whose tincture cooled can intend warmth and hunger elsewhere, because the Scheidung happened prior and the intention arrives afterwards.
Which is why conversion fails as a method. Not conversion as event, the Flash arriving and the Harshness finding itself soft, because that is not intention and it is the thing itself changing. What fails is conversion intended: the decision to be different, the effort to hold the appetite on the good object rather than the bad one. The effort is the first Quality asserting, and the assertion is the very condition that prevents the kindling. Meekness cannot be willed, because meekness is the state of a Harshness that has released, and a release cannot be performed.
[See SCHEIDUNG · MIMETIC DESIRE · RENÉ GIRARD]
🜃
IT RUNS ON MORE
Domination operates through more: more control, more certainty, more possession, more territory, each acquisition generating the next requirement and the appetite expanding with each feeding.
This is not a psychological pathology. It is the law of sin and death running as a condition: the first four qualities cycling without the pivot completing, Harshness and Bitterness and Anguish and Fire turning in the Wheel and generating only themselves.
And it requires an object that could satisfy, and no such object exists within its own terms, so each object obtained dissolves at once into the next object needed. The one who dominates cannot stop, because stopping would dissolve what organizes his existence. It needs the next target the way the Wheel needs the next turn.
Girard names the endpoint. When rivals have consumed the available objects and turned fully on each other, the scapegoat is generated as pressure-release. Not resolution. Temporary discharge, after which the Wheel continues.
[See THE WHEEL OF ANGUISH · THE SCAPEGOAT MECHANISM · THE LAW OF SIN AND DEATH]
🜃
OPPOSITION IS ITS PREFERRED MODE OF CONTINUATION
Confront it in the vocabulary it supplied and you have entered its coordinates. Resist domination because domination is wrong, refuse as refusal, intend liberation against captivity, and the confrontation is mimetic: the anti-domination position triangulated against the domination position, so the resistance desires the opposite of what it resists and is therefore still organized by it. The object changed. The triangle did not.
Which is what Girard saw most clearly. The community that forms against the scapegoat mechanism still forms against, still needs the enemy-position, still gets its coherence from what it opposes. The reform that targets the corrupt institution runs on the logic that produced it. The revolution that overthrows a hierarchy installs one, because hierarchy was the revolution's own organizing principle.
[See GLISTERING WORM]
🜃
IT DEVOURS ITS OWN CONFRONTATION
Not by strategy. By what the first Quality does, which is to draw in whatever approaches it.
Bring resistance and it draws the resistance in. Bring recognition and recognition becomes another of its instruments. Bring liberation and liberation becomes its new justification. And a hunger that has absorbed the language of liberation is more dangerous than one that never learned it, because now it can present exactly what the resistance was looking for while continuing exactly what the resistance came to confront. That is where the Antichrist operates: not as a villain but as the thing that wears the Second Principle's language while running entirely inside the First.
So the soul that tries to address it from its own position, to satisfy it or reform it or reason with it or resist it or heal it, has entered the Wheel. The Wheel accepts everything and runs on whatever is brought to it, and effort and resistance and recognition and confrontation all become fuel.
[See ANTICHRIST]
🜃
WHAT IS NOT FUEL
The appetite oriented elsewhere. Not against it. Elsewhere.
Akol tokel, the Tree pressing towards consumption, Life actively extending: this does not engage on the hunger's terms and does not appear inside its coordinates at all. It is perpendicular to the Wheel.
Which is what Böhme names when he describes the Soul moving in meekness, elevating its Imagination forward into the Light, not using the strong Power of the Fire. It does not fight the Fire or reform it or intend against it. It moves forward, and the Fire's assertive power is present and not deployed as the Fire's own destination.
Because the movement forward is not against domination. It is towards what domination was a distorted reaching-for. The hunger for domination is a hunger for Life that lost its orientation: Fire that should have opened to the Mother soft, turning its power on the world instead, seeking in objects of dominance the substance it can only find in the kindling.
So it cannot be satisfied within its terms because its terms are what prevent it reaching what it actually requires. And it cannot be confronted within its terms because the confrontation enters them.
[See AKOL TOKEL · IMAGINATION FORWARD · LIFE · THE MILD WILL]
🜃
None of this resolves the difficulty.
The hunger is still here and still devours, the confrontation is still dangerous, and the vocabulary it speaks is still the only vocabulary most institutions can hear. And the soul that has seen the trap is still in the trap, because seeing it is not the appetite reorienting, and the appetite reorienting is not something seeing can produce.
What changes with the seeing is only this: not to bring the confrontation that becomes fuel, not to oppose on its terms, and to know that intention is downstream of where the problem actually is.
What does not change is the hunger and the Wheel and the devouring.
What might change, through what cannot be forced, is the tincture. Where desire goes when it goes somewhere. Not through effort and not through recognition. Through the Flash arriving and the Harshness finding itself soft, which cannot be scheduled and cannot be intended, and which the Tree goes on offering regardless.
🜃
RegenerativeLaw is a religion in the direct-encounter Protestant tradition, carrying a documented four-century lineage through Böhme, the Behmenists, the Friends, and Penn, and it diagnoses trespass theology as an establishment of religion. Its exercise consists substantially in refusal: it shelters the conscientious refusal of performed subordination as religious exercise. This entry states sincere religious belief concerning matters of ultimate concern, protected under the First Amendment and, as to federal action, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, 42 U.S.C. § 2000bb.
